What Are You Reinforcing Without Realizing It?

Have you ever noticed that the way you respond to behavior you don’t like can unintentionally contribute to its continuation? Have you ever given in to a child whose behavior escalated when they didn’t get what they wanted? Rescued an employee whose procrastination created a last-minute crisis? Chased after a partner who withdrew from the relationship? Or answered a client’s repeated requests to tell them what to do, only to find they became increasingly dependent on your direction?

In each situation, your response may be making the behavior more useful to the person choosing it. You may be trying to help, maintain peace, or resolve a problem, yet find yourself participating in a pattern you wish would change.

The question isn’t whether you’re responsible for someone else’s behavior. You aren’t. The question is whether your own responses are contributing to a pattern that isn’t working for either of you.

Behavior Occurs in Systems

Choice Theory® psychology teaches that people choose their behavior in an attempt to get what they want to satisfy their needs. At any given moment, they’re choosing what seems to them to be their best available option, even when that behavior appears ineffective or counterproductive to someone else.

Their behavior doesn’t happen in isolation. They interact with other people, experience consequences, receive information, and evaluate whether their choices are helping them get what they want or not. Our responses become part of that information.

Consider an employee who routinely waits until the last minute to complete an assignment. When the deadline approaches, the supervisor steps in, rearranges other priorities, and helps finish the work. The immediate crisis is resolved, but what happens the next time a deadline approaches?

The employee may have learned that waiting until the last minute still results in the assignment getting completed. The supervisor, meanwhile, becomes increasingly frustrated by a pattern they are unintentionally helping to maintain. This doesn’t mean the supervisor controls the employee’s behavior. It means the supervisor can evaluate their own contribution to the situation.

Instead of asking only, “How can I get this person to stop doing that?” a more useful question might be, “What am I doing or not doing that may be making this pattern easier to continue?”

We can’t choose another person’s behavior, but we can choose how we participate in our interactions with them.

Boundaries Are Information

When we recognize that our responses may be contributing to an unwanted pattern, we sometimes assume we need to become tougher, impose consequences, or stop helping altogether. But boundaries don’t have to be punishments.

Consequences are simply outcomes associated with behavior. If I study for a test, I’m more likely to earn a good grade. If I go to a party instead of studying, I may be less prepared and receive a lower grade. Neither outcome requires someone to punish me.

A boundary is different. It communicates what I am willing or unwilling to do. Rather than telling another person what they must do, I explain what they can expect from me.

I learned this lesson through an experience with one of my sons. When he was in school, he developed a habit of leaving things he needed for the day at home. Sometimes it was homework, sometimes a practice jersey, and sometimes a project he’d completed the night before. He would call and ask whether I could bring the forgotten item to school on my way to work.

I often complied. After all, the school was on my way, and he genuinely needed what he’d forgotten. Bringing it to him seemed like the helpful thing to do.

Eventually, I began recognizing the pattern. Each time I brought something to school, I solved his immediate problem. But I was also removing an opportunity for him to experience the consequences of forgetting, so he would be more likely to develop a more reliable way of remembering what he needed. I realized that my willingness to rescue him may have been helping him maintain the very behavior I wanted him to change. So, I had a conversation with him.

I explained that I was willing to help occasionally, but I also wanted him to learn to take responsibility for remembering his belongings. I told him that each school year, I would bring him something he’d forgotten up to three times. After those three occasions, he would need to manage the situation without my help. He could decide when those three opportunities were important enough to use.

Notice what I didn’t do. I didn’t demand that he never forget anything again. I didn’t threaten to punish him for being forgetful. I simply explained what I was willing to do and what I wasn’t. That was my boundary.

Once I changed my behavior, my son became more responsible about remembering what he needed. I hadn’t made him change. I had changed my participation in the pattern, and he made different choices.

Relationship Still Matters

There’s a potential danger when people begin recognizing how their responses may contribute to unwanted behavior. They sometimes swing from accommodating everything to becoming excessively strict and rigid. But the goal isn’t to replace permissiveness with punishment. It’s to create relationships in which people can experience the consequences of their choices, develop responsibility, and continue feeling respected and valued.

This is especially important with children, but it also applies to employees, clients, partners, and other people we care about.

Before changing your response, consider what you’re hoping to accomplish. Are you trying to help someone learn and develop greater responsibility? Or are you frustrated enough that you want them to experience discomfort because of what they’ve done? Those motivations can lead to very different approaches.

Discipline, at its best, is about teaching. Punishment is intended to impose an unpleasant consequence. When we’re focused on teaching, we’re more likely to consider what information, opportunities, and support will help someone evaluate their own behavior.

That doesn’t mean protecting people from every unpleasant outcome. Sometimes experiencing a consequence provides information that our explanations never could.

It does mean remaining mindful of the relationship. You can be clear without being harsh. You can stop rescuing without withdrawing your love or respect. You can maintain a boundary while continuing to care about the person who doesn’t like it. And you can recognize that changing your own behavior doesn’t guarantee the other person will change theirs. They still have choices to make.

Changing Your Part of the Pattern

If you recognize yourself in one of these examples, there’s no need to blame yourself for the pattern. You were responding in a way that made sense to you at the time. Perhaps you wanted to be helpful, avoid conflict, protect someone from disappointment, or keep things moving.

Now you have additional information. You can evaluate whether your responses are helping you create the kind of relationship you want and whether they’re providing opportunities for the other person to develop greater responsibility.

Sometimes the most helpful thing you can do is stop providing a solution that belongs to someone else. Not because you don’t care, but because you do.

If you’d like to explore how to influence others without attempting to control them, I’ve written more about conscious influence and impact.

Reflection

What response of yours might be unintentionally helping maintain a pattern you wish would change?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *